Haig is saying how nothing can go wrong and that everyone is full of confidence. Get Full Essay Get access to this section to get all help you need with your essay and educational issues. What is much less widely known is that 78 British and Dominion officers of the rank of Brigadier General and above died on active service in the First World War while a further were wounded.
He was one of them who called Haig a Butcher. It would be unfair to call Haig incompetent as this was a completely different kind of war and he did not have any experience in fighting this type of war.
Despite plenty of careful planning many losses were sustained by all parties. Coppard is saying that leadership by the commanders is rubbish. It also praises Haig for his grate commandership.
During the Somme, Haig and Rawlinson failed to understand the best way of using artillery. This source is very useful for us knowing more about General Haig at the time, in the cartoon, the major general is addressing the men before an attack behind the lines.
Saying this General implies that the victory was all because of Haig. This source is reliable because given the fact that it was written by a Prime Minister of Britain during WW1.
They might want to get their ground ready, for the next war. Which made the people bitter and angry especially the anger from the men in the Front line, seeing Haig standing kilometers behind them, thinking that he was being a coward, and the ones who lost their family and relatives on the 1st of July?
On a final note, the author devotes a chapter of the book to quotes from soldiers overwhelmingly Australian condemning British generalship. On every measure of historical rigour, thorough research and academic objectivity this book fails miserably. He sent 50, Britain to death just for one day. He graduated the following year in as an officer.
He is willing to sacrifice the lives of thousands of his men for the glory of victory. It can be trusted because it was written by a person who was in the battle who experienced what the war was like and what Haig was doing. In World War Two, armoured vehicles were used for this purpose, but the tanks of Great War vintage were simply not up to the job.
The source supports the point that Douglas Haig is the Butcher of the battle of the Somme. I have read hastily cobbled together undergraduate essays that have more comprehensive footnotes.
In previous wars, horsed cavalry had performed such a role, but cavalry were generally of little use in the trenches of the Western Front.
He repeated the mistakes opposite of what was said organized. In a surprise attack, massed artillery opened up in a brief but devastating bombardment, targeting German gun batteries and other key positions. As the historian Ian Malcolm Brown has pointed out in his recent book British Logistics on the Western Font Praegerall this was made possible by an excellent administrative and transport system that, innot only enabled Haig to deliver attacks of tremendous power but also to switch the point of attack to another sector at short notice - so keeping the Germans off balance.
Quite as many died on the wire as on the ground. Eventually the allies won the First World War. The main People who seem to be criticising Haig is the men that he commanded.
By Amiens, aeroplanes were considerably more sophisticated than their predecessors of Another part which is correct is when the source is telling us about the German confidence.
Haig was the product of his time, of his upbringing, education, and training and previous military experience. From the information he had been given he thought he could easily breakthrough the enemy lines.Mar 10, · British Butchers and Bunglers of World War One by John Laffin (Sutton, ) Western Front by Richard Holmes (BBC, ) The Evolution of Victory by Andy Simpson (Tom Donovan, ) Links.
First World War This website features information on the origins and battles of World War One, and includes photographs and a timeline. May 01, · British Butchers and Bunglers of World War I by John Laffin,available at Book Depository with free delivery worldwide/5(21).
During the period known as the "Hundred Days", the British and Dominion divisions on the Western Front won a dozen major victories - the greatest series of victories in the British Army's whole history, and also the only time in British history that the British Army has engaged and defeated the main body of the main enemy in a continental war.
Source D comes from the book called ‘British Butchers and Bunglers of World War’. The first line reads: ‘Haig was stubborn as a donkey and unthinking as a donkey’. The title suggests that this the book is going to be biased against the generals in the war and there is hardly any evaluation of what happened.
This military book titled ' BRITISH BUTCHERS & BUNGLERS WORLD WAR 1 ' by John Laffin is a study of how so many Australians died during WW1 under British command. This book has got the sort of title - "British Butchers" - that ordinarily I would not be particularly attracted to, as it sounds like some sort of anti-war 'rant', probably a pacifist tract, as were so many books about World War One, or "The Great War", as it was known in its day, and as it still is known in Europe.Download